Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of 26 included studies

From: Effect of Astragalus injection treatment for viral myocarditis: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Author

Year

Intervention

Dose

Course of treatment

Gender (male/female)

Average age

Outcomes

C

Astragalus injection

Wang Zhaohui

2001

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 20 g + 5%GS 500ML, ivgtt, qd

3 m

30/20

27/39

32

CK, cTnl

Wu Qiaoyan

2009

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection ~ 2 mL/kg, ivgtt, qd

11–31 d

17/13

18/12

7.5

ECG

Wang Fuyu

2001

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 20–30 ml + 5%GS 150–200ML, ivgtt, qd

3 w

23/27

22/28

24.72

LDH, AST, ECG

Xi Zhongxin

2012

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 40 ml + 5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, tid,

6 m

29/41

31/52

40.2

CK,CK-MB,LDH, AST,ECG

Sun XiangRong

2005

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 30 ml + 5%GS 150–200ML, ivgtt, qd

4 w

18/16

18/17

28

AST, CK-MB

Luo Chengxiang

2008

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 6–10 ml + 10%GS 250ML, ivgtt, qd

1–4 w

37/26

36/24

7.7

ECG

Peng Yongjun

2006

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 10–20 ml + 10%GS 50–100ML, ivgtt, qd

14 d

22/18

24/16

6

AST, CK-MB, LDH, CK, cTnl, ECG

Lu Zuozheng

2004

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 10 ml, ivgtt, qd

3–4 w

12/11

18/17

7

AST, CK-MB, LDH, CK

Liu Jin

2017

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 15 ml + 5%GS 100ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

31/21

30/22

5.7

AST, CK-MB, LDH, CK

Wang Yuehua

2013

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 2.5 mg/kg·d + 5%GS 100–200ML, ivgtt, qd

15 d

16/15

26/21

7.4

CK-MB

Yuan Binli

2008

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 10–20 ml + 10%GS 150–200ML, ivgtt, qd

3 w

13/11

14/12

8

ECG

Lu Yanmei

2010

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 10–20 ml + 10%GS 100–250ML, ivgtt, qd

10–14 d

20/10

17/13

5

AST, CK-MB, LDH, CK

Zhang Lisheng

2010

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 1 mL/kg ~ 2 mL/kg, ivgtt, qd

42 d

22/18

23/17

9

CK-MB, cTnl

Xu Muzhen

2010

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 0.2 g/kg + 5%GS 10–20ML, ivgtt, qd

14 d

16/14

20/18

7.32

CK-MB, cTnl

Zhang Defeng

2001

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 1 ~ 2 m l / k g·d + 10%GS 100–250ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

42/36

34/50

8.3

CK-MB, LDH

Hu Xiaofeng

2009

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 60 ml + 5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, bid

2 w

27/23

26/24

37

AST, CK-MB, LDH, CK, cTnl

Lu yingfen

2000

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 30 ml, ivgtt + 0.9%Nacl 500ML, ivgtt, qd

4 w

23/17

27/19

37.3

LDH, ECG

zhou zhilin

2003

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 30ml5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

12/19

14/18

34

CK-MB, AST, ECG

Wei Ao

2020

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 20ml5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

48/42

50/40

70

CK-MB, LDH, cTnl, ECG

Zhang Yisheng

2013

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 30ml5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, qd

4 w

22/16

28/20

25

CK-MB, cTnl

Wu Bing

2016

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 20 ml + 5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

24/23

21/26

26

CK-MB, cTnl, LDH

Xie Honhying

2021

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 20 ml + 5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

42/38

43/37

45

CK-MB, cTnl

Yang Wenjun

2022

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 20 ml + 5%GS 250ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

35/35

37/33

58.7

CK-MB, cTnl, LDH

Li Wangxuan

2018

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 20 ml, ivgtt, qd

2 w

36/26

38/24

30

CK-MB, cTnI, LDH, CK

Liu Ningning

2021

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 5 ~ 10 ml + 10%GS 100–150ML, ivgtt, qd

2 w

35/28

33/30

40

CK, CK-MB, LDH

Wang Honglei

2019

Astragalus injection + C

Astragalus injection 30 ml, ivgtt, qd

2 w

27/20

26/22

5

CK-MB, cTnl, LDH

  1. T: treatment group; C: control group; Ivgtt: intravenous glucose tolerance test; CK: creatine kinase; CK-MB: creatine kinase isoenzyme; LDH: lactate dehydrogenase; cTnI: cardiac troponin I; AST: aspartate aminotransferase and electrocardiogram (ECG)